Sugar Pie Suite

InnCaroline Street 537, Key West, FL, United StatesShow on map

You won’t be charged yet

Check-in from 4:00 PMCheck-out by 10:00 AM.
Very good locationGuests rate the location 8.1 out of 10, at Caroline Street 537.

Central Location Located in the heart of Key West, Sugar Pie Suite by Brightwild offers a convenient stay close to major attractions such as Key West Aquarium, Mallory Dock, and Duval Street.

Comfortable Amenities Enjoy a cozy stay with air conditioning, free WiFi, TV, and a patio. The apartment also provides towels, bed linen, and a private entrance for added privacy.

Relaxing Outdoor Pool Unwind by the outdoor pool or explore nearby beaches like Simonton Street Beach, South Beach, and Fort Zachary Taylor State Park Beach.

Experience the perfect blend of comfort and convenience at Sugar Pie Suite by Brightwild. Book now for an unforgettable stay in Key West.

What this place offers

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Garden
Pets allowed
Fishing
Cycling
Golf course
Non-smoking throughout

Rooms

3.5

Guest rating

Rated 3.5 out of 10 by 2 guests who stayed here.

Cleanliness7.5
Service8.3
Location8.1
Rooms7.8
Amenities7.2
Value6.9
Food & drink7.3

Guests mention

Clean roomsFriendly staffGreat locationComfortable beds

SarahUnited States
February 2025
Great location, clean, but small and overpriced room.
Location was great. Room was very clean.
Room was small; nowhere to set anything. For what we got, I felt room was extremely overpriced. Needed a small desk or table. Bed support was broken, and outlet was loose and…
ValeriiUnited States
August 2023
Bad
They don’t have parking
Small room
Ant living in bathroom
Parking 40$ per day

Reviews are written by guests who booked through our supplier and stayed, shown as written and in their own language. Category scores are the supplier’s reading of recent reviews, updated June 2025.

Where you’ll be

Caroline Street 537, Key West, FL, United States

Guests rate the location 8.1 out of 10 — very good.

Things to know

Cancellation

Each room shows its own terms before you pay.

Most rates can be cancelled free until a date shown on the room.

Non-refundable rates are marked as such.

House rules

Check-in from 4:00 PM

Check-out by 10:00 AM

Children welcome

No pets

Payment & property

Paid when you book, not at the desk.

Rates include the taxes and fees we can read.

The property may take a card at check-in for incidentals.

What we’d check for you here

The pet fee and any size limit, which is where these bookings usually come apart.
Whether the rate moves for your dates, and what it includes.
What the property actually charges at the desk on top of the rate.

Questions about Sugar Pie Suite

What time is check-in and check-out at Sugar Pie Suite?

Check-in is from 4:00 PM. Check-out is by 10:00 AM. If you're arriving late, tell us and we'll ask the property to hold the room.

Does Sugar Pie Suite allow pets?

No — the property states that pets are not allowed.

Does Sugar Pie Suite have a pool?

Yes — a pool is listed among the property's facilities. Seasonal closures are common, so we'll confirm it's open for your dates.

Does Sugar Pie Suite have Wi-Fi?

Yes — internet access is listed among the property's facilities.

How do I book Sugar Pie Suite?

Put your dates in above and book online, or call (888) 789-8585 and we'll do it for you — including things a booking form can't handle, like a block of rooms, a monthly rate or an invoice for your employer.

Where is Sugar Pie Suite?

Caroline Street 537, Key West, FL.

Other places we book in Key West

Nothing to do with the booking above. The same market, priced the same way, for if this one is not it.

All stays inKey West, FL

Almond Tree Inn - Adults Only9.8 · 610 reviews

Orchid Key Inn - Adults Only9.8 · 560 reviews

The Gardens Hotel9.8 · 329 reviews

Ambrosia Key West9.6 · 1157 reviews

Bishop Hotel Key West9.8 · 183 reviews

Places to stay Key West, FL