Open Hearth Lodge
Hotel, 2-star2669 S Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, 54234, Sister Bay, WI, United StatesShow on map
Exceptional
One of our highest-scored stays, according to its guests.
9.6171Reviews- Check-in from 3:30 PMCheck-out by 11:00 AM.
- Exceptional locationGuests rate the location 10.0 out of 10, at 2669 S Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, 54234.
- Breakfast availableIncluded on some rates — the board is shown on each room.
Indoor Pool, Spa Tub, and Sauna Enjoy the relaxation and rejuvenation with our indoor pool, spa tub, and sauna.
Complimentary Breakfast and Amenities Start your day right with our daily complimentary continental breakfast. Plus, take advantage of our computer station, luggage storage, and laundry facilities.
Comfortable Rooms with Free Wi-Fi Unwind in our air-conditioned rooms with free Wi-Fi and cable programming. Feel at home with amenities like refrigerators, desks, and daily housekeeping.
Experience comfort and convenience at Open Hearth Lodge. Book your stay now for a relaxing getaway near the beach.
What this place offers
- Elevator
- Fitness facilities
- Golfing nearby
- Cross-country skiing nearby
- Fireplace in lobby
- Hiking/biking trails nearby
- Kayaking nearby
- Sailing nearby
- Television in common areas
- Free breakfast
Rooms
9.6
Exceptional
Rated 9.6 out of 10 by 171 guests who stayed here.
- Cleanliness9.0
- Service10.0
- Location10.0
- Rooms8.9
- Amenities10.0
- Value9.9
- Food & drink9.0
Guests mention
Friendly staffGood locationClean facilitiesDog-friendlyNice amenities
PaulOnly 1 thing that is negative
Pool and spa opened late and closed early
We are early risers and wanted to use the spa especially
We get closing pool to kids but it could have stayed open for adults a while longer
MaureenStaff were fantastic and friendly! The whole place is very well kept up and very clean! We loved sitting at the campfire. We will be coming back in the future.
JackieThe entire property was very well maintained, nicely decorated/modern-contemporary. Every staff member we met was very friendly. We liked the location of resort as well as it's right in the middle of Door County with…
RosaliaVery pleasant
ChristyThis was a great stay and def would come back it’s in the perfect area where you can get anywhere
KarenAmazing service, amazing facilities and amazing pet friendliness!!
Highly, highly recommended to stay with a pet or not.
Reviews are written by guests who booked through our supplier and stayed, shown as written and in their own language. Category scores are the supplier’s reading of recent reviews, updated January 2026.
Where you’ll be
2669 S Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, 54234, Sister Bay, WI, United States
Guests rate the location 10.0 out of 10 — exceptional.
Things to know
Cancellation
Each room shows its own terms before you pay.
Most rates can be cancelled free until a date shown on the room.
Non-refundable rates are marked as such.
House rules
Check-in from 3:30 PM until 10:00 PM
Check-out by 11:00 AM
No children
Show more
No pets
The front desk is open daily from 7:30 AM - 10 PM. To make arrangements for check-in please contact the property at least 48 hours before arrival using the information on the booking confirmation. If you are planning to arrive after 10:00 PM please contact the property in advance using the information on the booking confirmation. Guests must contact the property in advance for check-in instructions. The front desk is staffed during limited hours.
Pets. Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions
General. Professional property host/manager
Pets. Service animals are allowed
Payment & property
Paid when you book, not at the desk.
Rates include the taxes and fees we can read.
The property may take a card at check-in for incidentals.
Show more
The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation. A deposit may be required at the property.
What we’d check for you here
- That the step-free room is actually free on your dates, and whether it is a roll-in shower or a bath, which the listing never says.
- Whether there is room for a pickup, a trailer or a van, not just a car.
- Whether breakfast is in the rate or added at checkout, and what time it runs.
- Whether the rate moves for your dates, and what it includes.
- What the property actually charges at the desk on top of the rate.
Questions about Open Hearth Lodge
What time is check-in and check-out at Open Hearth Lodge?
Check-in is from 3:30 PM. Check-out is by 11:00 AM. If you're arriving late, tell us and we'll ask the property to hold the room.
Does Open Hearth Lodge allow pets?
No — the property states that pets are not allowed.
Is there parking at Open Hearth Lodge?
Parking is listed among the property's facilities. Whether it's free and whether a space can be reserved varies, so we check it against your dates rather than promise it here.
Does Open Hearth Lodge have a pool?
Yes — a pool is listed among the property's facilities. Seasonal closures are common, so we'll confirm it's open for your dates.
Is breakfast included at Open Hearth Lodge?
Breakfast is offered at the property. Whether it's included depends on the rate — the board type is shown on each room once you put your dates in.
Does Open Hearth Lodge have Wi-Fi?
Yes — internet access is listed among the property's facilities.
Does Open Hearth Lodge have wheelchair accessible rooms?
The property lists step-free or accessible facilities. That flag is the one least able to settle the question: a hotel can carry it and still have a step at the entrance, or a bath rather than a roll-in shower, and it does not say whether the accessible room is free on your dates. Tell us what you need and we'll ask the property directly rather than reading you the flag.
How do I book Open Hearth Lodge?
Put your dates in above and book online, or call (888) 789-8585 and we'll do it for you — including things a booking form can't handle, like a block of rooms, a monthly rate or an invoice for your employer.
Where is Open Hearth Lodge?
2669 S Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin, 54234, Sister Bay, WI.
Other places we book in Sister Bay
Nothing to do with the booking above. The same market, priced the same way, for if this one is not it.
Scandinavian Lodge9.2 · 213 reviews
Country House Resort9.4 · 436 reviews
Goose & Twigs9.4 · 135 reviews
Sister Bay Inn9.1 · 473 reviews
Pheasant Park Resort9.1 · 189 reviewsThe Inn at Little Sister HillBirchwood LodgeDownTown InnThe Liberty Lodge at Sister BayCoachlite InnLuxe Retreat with Sauna, Walk to Northern HausCherry Hill- Charming Sister Bay Home, Backyard Oasis, HotTubScandia- Secluded Home, Walk to Marina, Game Room & Hot TubWooded Wonder- Cozy Retreat, Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Game Room & Dogs!Cozy Birch Cabin Retreat -Mins to SisterBay MarinaThe Goat and Cherry- Cozy Retreat, Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Arcade Fun & Dogs!3 Mi to Sister Bay Beach: Family Home w/ YardCozy Sister Bay Getaway in Converted Barn!Door County Retreat ~ 3 Mi to Sister Bay BeachQuaint Sister Bay Studio w/ Large Backyard!Sister Sunset - Next 2 Al Johnsons, Skip Stone, SB Beach! Hot Tub!Three Sister's Cottage BarnUpdated Home w/ Deck: 2 Mi to Sister Bay Beach!Bird's Nest- Perfect Retreat for 2, Studio Above Bakery, Dogs!The Nordic Lodge