Faraway Sag Harbor
Hotel, 4-star31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY, United StatesShow on map
Fabulous
Guests rate it highest for location, amenities and service.
8.9253Reviews- Check-in from 4:00 PMCheck-out by 11:00 AM. The front desk is staffed around the clock, so a late arrival is fine.
- Superb locationGuests rate the location 9.5 out of 10, at 31 W. Water Street.
- Free parkingThe property states parking on site is free for guests.
Luxurious Accommodations Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor offers elegantly furnished guest rooms equipped with modern amenities, including flat-screen TVs and luxurious bathrobes. Select rooms even provide stunning views of the sea or garden, ensuring a memorable stay.
Gourmet Dining Experience Indulge in a culinary journey at the on-site restaurant, where you can savor fresh American cuisine for lunch and dinner daily. Treat yourself to a delightful breakfast and brunch on the weekends, promising a delectable start to your day.
Leisure and Activities From relaxing by the seasonal saltwater swimming pool to exploring the picturesque surroundings on a bike hired from the hotel, Baron's Cove provides ample opportunities for leisure and recreation. The 24-hour front desk is always ready to assist, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable stay.
Book your stay at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor today for a luxurious and unforgettable experience.
What this place offers
- Fitness facilities
- WiFi available
- Free WiFi
- Parking
- Free Parking
- Non-smoking rooms
- Air conditioning
- Fitness center
- Swimming pool
- 24-hour front desk
Rooms
8.9
Fabulous
Rated 8.9 out of 10 by 253 guests who stayed here.
- Cleanliness8.0
- Service9.4
- Location9.5
- Rooms8.4
- Amenities9.5
- Value8.4
- Food & drink9.0
Guests mention
Great locationFriendly staffComfortable amenitiesGood food and beverage optionsRelaxing atmosphere
StellaItalyNon lo suggerirei…
Molto bella la piscina e l’utilizzo gratuito delle biciclette. Posizione centrale ma allo stesso tempo tranquillo. Hotel arredato con stile!! Molto stile! Ma camera da letto deludente.
Con affaccio sul parcheggio -…
NathalieUnited StatesI rarely write negative reviews, but I feel compelled to warn other travelers.
This hotel is a classic example of “a pig with lipstick on.” While it has been remodeled, it still feels like an old motel underneath, and…
ReemUnited Arab EmiratesLovely stay but way over priced for services
Lovely design and decoration of period buildings and port cabins. I liked the cafe area and bar and the mattresses were very comfortable.
The amenities were very basic and the hotel charges were exuberant. Did not match…
Charies JUnited StatesVery relaxing!
Very Nice.
KatherineParking was free and really easy. Great proximity to the main street of town—you can easily walk, but it's not too close where it gets loud at night. The front staff and cleaning team were all lovely and super helpful.…
andrewstaff seemed tired and fed up of people staying!
Reviews are written by guests who booked through our supplier and stayed, shown as written and in their own language. Category scores are the supplier’s reading of recent reviews, updated December 2025.
Where you’ll be
31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY, United States
Guests rate the location 9.5 out of 10 — superb.
Things to know
Cancellation
Each room shows its own terms before you pay.
Most rates can be cancelled free until a date shown on the room.
Non-refundable rates are marked as such.
House rules
Check-in from 4:00 PM
Check-out by 11:00 AM
Children welcome
Show more
No pets
Free parking on site
Non-smoking rooms available
Payment & property
Paid when you book, not at the desk.
Rates include the taxes and fees we can read.
The property may take a card at check-in for incidentals.
Show more
Our seasonal outdoor swimming pool is open from Memorial Day and closes on the Sunday of Columbus Day Weekend *Weather permitting.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. A deposit may be required at the property.
What we’d check for you here
- How many rooms they will hold at once, for how long, and on what terms.
- That the step-free room is actually free on your dates, and whether it is a roll-in shower or a bath, which the listing never says.
- That the desk is staffed when you land, and that the room is held past cut-off.
- The pet fee and any size limit, which is where these bookings usually come apart.
- Whether there is room for a pickup, a trailer or a van, not just a car.
- Whether breakfast is in the rate or added at checkout, and what time it runs.
- Whether the rate moves for your dates, and what it includes.
- What the property actually charges at the desk on top of the rate.
Questions about Faraway Sag Harbor
What time is check-in and check-out at Faraway Sag Harbor?
Check-in is from 4:00 PM. Check-out is by 11:00 AM. If you're arriving late, tell us and we'll ask the property to hold the room.
Does Faraway Sag Harbor allow pets?
No — the property states that pets are not allowed.
Is there parking at Faraway Sag Harbor?
Yes — the property states that parking on site is free. Whether a space can be reserved in advance varies, so we check it against your dates.
Does Faraway Sag Harbor have a pool?
Yes — a pool is listed among the property's facilities. Seasonal closures are common, so we'll confirm it's open for your dates.
Is breakfast included at Faraway Sag Harbor?
Breakfast is offered at the property. Whether it's included depends on the rate — the board type is shown on each room once you put your dates in.
Does Faraway Sag Harbor have Wi-Fi?
Yes — internet access is listed among the property's facilities.
Can I book a block of rooms at Faraway Sag Harbor?
The property lists meeting and banquet space, which usually means it handles group business — but how many rooms it will hold at once, for how long, and at what rate are set case by case and are not in any feed. Tell us the dates and the number of rooms and we'll get those terms from the property in writing before anything is charged.
Does Faraway Sag Harbor have wheelchair accessible rooms?
The property lists step-free or accessible facilities. That flag is the one least able to settle the question: a hotel can carry it and still have a step at the entrance, or a bath rather than a roll-in shower, and it does not say whether the accessible room is free on your dates. Tell us what you need and we'll ask the property directly rather than reading you the flag.
Can I check in late at Faraway Sag Harbor?
The property lists a front desk staffed 24 hours, so a late arrival should be possible. Standard check-in is from 4:00 PM. Rooms are still released after a cut-off at some properties regardless of the desk hours, so tell us your arrival time and we'll have them hold it.
How do I book Faraway Sag Harbor?
Put your dates in above and book online, or call (888) 789-8585 and we'll do it for you — including things a booking form can't handle, like a block of rooms, a monthly rate or an invoice for your employer.
Where is Faraway Sag Harbor?
31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY.
Other places we book in Sag Harbor
Nothing to do with the booking above. The same market, priced the same way, for if this one is not it.
Sag Harbor Inn9.1 · 218 reviews
Cowgirl Palace6.7 · 20 reviews
Awarded Lux Sanctuary Pike Pond by Rovetravel
Bluffside Cove by Rove Beachfront w Pool Sauna
Breakwater by Rove Travel - 3BR Secluded RetreatMeadowood Manor by Rove Travel - 6BR Outdoor SpacesMeadowood Manor by Rove Travel 6 BR Sag HarborMeadowood Manor by Rovetravel Heated PoolRobeson RetreatSunset Villa by Rove Beachfront w Deck PoolVilla Ebrar - Luxury with poolVilla KeyLimeVilla Kimaal - Luxury with poolVilla LavenderVilla MachisVilla Zainip - Luxury with pool